Masculinity’s Delayed Adolesence

Though women’s issues tend to get the majority of media attention in this country, in the book “Guyland” sociologist Michael Kimmel elegantly elicits his thesis that young men are silently struggling, especially in the 18-30 “delayed adolescence” age group, with the puzzle of post-modern masculinity in a post-feminist world.

First of all, as a sort of disclaimer, anything I write here is going to be an oversimplification; but an oversimplification for the sake of illustrating an idea. Let’s start with this one: on the whole women have adapted to the rapidly changing cultural landscape more effectively than men. That’s because women, collectively reacting to men in power through generations upon generations of society, have had to develop psychological and social flexibility to survive and empower themselves as a class. When those efforts finally became organized at the broad social level in the 20th century, real change in society resulted. Real change that affected men every bit as much as women, but for men without any sense of ownership. Thus the troubling sense for many men that feminism “happened to them,” the state of confusion and loss of identity that followed. A state for men that society is still frankly reeling from.

* * *

Men as a whole have never gone through “feminism,” because there has never been a stage of men collectively discovering and asserting their power to overcome repression. That makes women, as a whole, much more developmentally (in the sense of culture and their place in it) advanced than men.

It’s a little like adolescence. Sometime around the ages of twelve to fifteen the child begins to challenge the authority of their parents in an effort to make an identity separate from them. The battles of identity, rebellion and self-definition that ensue from this urge to individuate drive most parents crazy, but are a critical step in the psychological transition from childhood to adulthood.

“Womankind,” to use a term that I dislike as a writer but find oddly accurate for conveying this sense of a class or group, collectively went through adolescence in the 20th century, the most dramatic battles of civil rights for women, and identity for the parallel teenage girl, having been fought by the time the first digit struck two.

As any fan of my thinking knows, I’m always one for an ongoing analogy, so why stop there. Any parent of teenagers could tell you that teenage girls seem to experience adolescence both much earlier and much more acutely than males. Part of this is biological, girls start physically developing around thirteen and slow down significantly by age eighteen. Men on the other hand don’t begin developing physically until fifteen, and for many men it can go on into their early-twenties. The end result of this pattern of development is that by the time a man and a women each reach the age of twenty-five the woman has been in her body for close to seven years, and the man is just getting comfortable.

And, you’ve no doubt already guessed where I’m going with this, so goes the story of masculinity’s emerging maturity. As usual, we are just a few years behind the girls.

While feminism rocked our culture throughout the second half of the 20th century like a sixteen year old girl’s cigarette-smoking-goth-rock phase, masculine development will likely more resemble young male development: after so many years of pounding light beer and playing Rock Band with no particular achievements to his name the twenty-something boy decides it’s time to make a little money and gradually, over the course of many more years than the dramatic and condensed female version, grows into a man by imitating the mature male role models in his life.

Which means we probably won’t see a broad scale “Masculinism” emerge as dramatically and publicly as Feminism. But make no mistake, the maturity of masculinity, like the boyish twenty-four-year-olds who populate Kimmel’s Guyland, is long overdue. Ladies, fear not: mature masculinity will be much more compatible with the current stage of female development. Mature masculinity will not mean a return to repression, but an embrace of the differences between men and women and the fun we can have with them.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Masculinity’s Delayed Adolesence

  1. Pingback: Art of Manliness Weekly Link Roundup: 10 Year Reunion Edition | The Art of Manliness

  2. A. Schultz

    “Men as a whole have never gone through “feminism,” because there has never been a stage of men collectively discovering and asserting their power to overcome repression.”

    My personal experience is that this “masculinism” is starting to take shape. Men around me (myself included) are starting to break through the castrated feeling that feminism has burdened them with and are starting to do this “discovering and asserting [of] their power.”
    I agree wholeheartedly with the closing lines of the article:
    “Mature masculinity will not mean a return to repression, but an embrace of the differences between men and women and the fun we can have with them.”
    Women who are with the men I’m referring to are not being repressed, but are advancing with their partners/male friends happily. It seems that these women actually have been craving for men to be men (truly manly men!). Our fathers left us to be raised by women and we are now seeing the folly of this. Little girls have long pined for their ‘Daddies’, and now the big boys want to know where Dad was when they should have been learning from him -learning what it is to be a man.
    I’m not sure if the maturing of masculinity will be drawn out as the article suggests, but it is certainly beginning.
    Young men (with the cheers of their middle-aged counter-parts) are realising that manliness and manhood are good. Blood, sweat and tears taste good (mmm, salty).

    -A. Schultz
    Age 25

  3. I hope I don’t come across as doctrinaire, but I see a parallel between the decline of adult fraternal organizations and a decline in masculine identity. A century ago, one in four men belonged to at least one fraternal organization. From ethnic organizations like the Sons of Italy, or the Hibernian Society, to religious groups like the Knights of Columbus, or the Brotherhood of B’nai Brith or the Orange Order, to groups based on fellowship like the Elks and the Eagles, to philanthropic and spiritual groups like the Masons, the Knights of Pythias and the Odd Fellows, men belonged to a group that chose them, mentored them, and nurtured them. A young man who will not listen to his father will learn from older men in his neighborhood or town if given a structure in which to interact with him. As men move to rediscover their masculinity, they are rediscovering the value of fraternal organizations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s